If You Owe the Bank $1 Million…

“If you owe the bank $1 million, the bank owns you.  If you owe $1 billion, you own the bank.”  Holman W. Jenkins, Jr.

“If you owe the bank $1 million, the bank owns you.  If you owe $1 billion, you own the bank.  If you owe several trillion, you are the financial system.  Libor is called a key underpinning of global finance. But that’s far more true of IOUs issued by the U.S. government and its major counterparts.  The global financial system is built on a mountain of government debt [$117 trillion and probably higher], and in turn banks and their governments are bedfellows of a highly incestuous order.

“That’s why, in every transcript and phone memorandum that has come to light, in talking about Libor, regulators and bankers talk to each other as if they were all just bankers talking amongst themselves.

“That’s why, when a high British official suggested that Barclays lowball its Libor submission during the financial crisis, Barclays didn’t hesitate because, as one banker testified to the British Parliament, these were government instructions ‘at a time when governments were tangibly calling the shots.’

“It’s ironic to think that some who championed the euro saw it as way to break free of rule by bankers. Europe’s new monetary authority would be focused on  producing a stable currency; Europe’s national governments would have no choice but to live within their means.

“This experiment failed because the European Central Bank quickly adopted policies designed to induce banks not to distinguish between the governments.  That is, the euro was immediately corrupted by the need to help governments keep financing themselves.

“Now the world is Europe.  Under the current regime of financial repression, banks and states are even more annexes of each other.  Notice Japan’s central bank explicitly stating plans to erode the value of the government’s debt in the hands of Japanese savers.  Notice the European Central Bank again hinting at readiness to buy the debt of countries no longer able to find voluntary buyers in the market.  In the U.S., how long before the Treasury issues a perpetual bond yielding zero percent for direct sale to the Fed?

“The banker-government consortium re-exposed in the Libor scandal won’t be unwound from the top, not when governments are more dependent than ever on a captive financial system to give their debt the illusion of viability.  And yet there’s still a possibility of unwinding it from the bottom, giving large numbers of bankers an incentive to get out of the government-insured sector and go back to a world in which they live by their own profits and losses.

“The solution begins with deposit-insurance reform.  The FDIC would stop insuring deposits that are invested in anything other than U.S. Treasury paper.  The FDIC would be charged solely with seizing these assets when a bank gets in trouble so the claims of insured depositors can be satisfied.  There’d be no call to bail out other creditors or shareholders to minimize the cost to the deposit insurance fund.

“Yes, the threat might be only semi-credible.  But such a law could be got through Congress and risk-averse lenders would become less interested in holding uninsured credit against banks that are too big to manage and too opaque to be viable without a government backstop.

“The J.P. Morgans, Citis and Bank of America would stampede to get smaller.  Finance could return to its natural role, arbitraging between good assets and bad ones.  Who knows, we may yet need that function again one day to get out of our debt mess.”  Holman W. Jenkins, Jr., The Wall Street Journal, July 28-29, 2012, p. A17


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: